The Supreme Court docket on Tuesday dismissed a lawyer’s plea searching for a ban on the usage of the slogan “Jai Shri Ram” throughout campaigning in poll-bound West Bengal, saying it discovered no floor to intervene. “At most, in a given scenario interesting on grounds of faith, the one energy obtainable is to method the excessive courtroom in an election petition in opposition to the successful candidate,” a Chief Justice of India SA Bobde-led bench mentioned.
ML Sharma, the lawyer, informed the courtroom that such spiritual slogans vitiate elections and added these elevating such slogans must be restrained and felony instances be lodged in opposition to them.
The courtroom gave Sharma the choice of approaching the Calcutta excessive courtroom. It dismissed the petition as he was unwilling to take action.
Additionally Learn | Delhi HC to listen to plea difficult new guidelines to control web content material
Sharma accused the Bharatiya Janata Get together (BJP), which is searching for to wrest energy in West Bengal after rising because the second-biggest get together within the state within the 2019 nationwide polls, of utilizing the slogan as a spiritual device whereas demanding submitting of instances in opposition to its high leaders for selling enmity by elevating it.
Sharma requested the courtroom to resolve whether or not the usage of a “provocative spiritual slogan” must be handled as an electoral offence underneath a provision of the Illustration of the Folks Act that seeks to test promotion of hatred on grounds of faith, race, caste, group or language.
“Utilizing the slogan ‘Jai Shri Ram’ is liable to be prohibited and whoever, particular person or get together or group of individual of a celebration makes use of it previous to election or throughout election or thereafter, should be prohibited to take part in election,” mentioned the plea.
BJP chief and Union minister Gajendra Singh Shekhawat, who’s answerable for 5 Lok Sabha constituencies in West Bengal, final month informed HT that “Jai Shri Ram” has turn out to be West Bengal’s election slogan.
“Jai Shri Ram” slogans have been raised at an occasion in Kolkata in January to mark the start anniversary of freedom fighter Subhas Chandra Bose. Chief minister Mamata Banerjee, who attended that programme together with Prime Minister Narendra Modi, was about to stroll as much as the dais for her speech when the slogan was raised. Subsequently, Banerjee refused to handle the viewers, saying the programme misplaced its dignity and he or she felt insulted. The BJP has focused Banerjee for getting irritated over the slogan.
Sharma’s plea additionally questioned the Election Fee’s choice to conduct the polling in West Bengal in eight phases as in opposition to three in Assam, and in a single section in Tamil Nadu, Kerala and Puducherry.
“Conducting election in eight phases whereas in a single section in different states, particularly when West Bengal just isn’t dealing with any terrorist assault or underneath disputed conflict zone…is a transparent case of violation of Article 14 [right to equality] of the Structure…,” mentioned the plea.